Supercharger vs Turbo

Posted on: 06/03/2014

For almost the entire time that both of them have been in existence, it has been a constant source of discussion as to which is better, the supercharger or the turbo.

Both of them seek to achieve the same enhancement in engine performance, by greatly increasing the amount of air going into the cylinder, thereby increasing the amount of fuel that can be burned, resulting in a higher power output. It’s the manner that both of these devices manage to do so where they differ.

The supercharger draws its power directly from the crankshaft by use of a belt, whilst the turbo utilizes otherwise wasted power, in the form of the exhaust gasses being thrust out of the engine operating the mechanism to pump more clean air in.

The immediate drawback to the supercharger is the use of power that would otherwise go to the drive being used up operating the supercharger impeller. A turbo doesn’t tax the engine at all, deriving all of its impetus from superheated exhaust being pushed out naturally. Game, Set, Match to the turbo then, you might think.

However, because the supercharger is attached to the crankshaft, its impact on the engine is far more immediate and predictable when the throttle is applied, meaning a much faster response when applying the accelerator. As you can imagine, in a racing environment for instance, this immediacy has definite advantages for the driver.

With a turbo, as it’s activated by the exhaust, there is a pause or ‘lag’ which in the past has made the turbo harder to manage in the fast moving world of racing, as the power comes on with a delay, when the pedal is pressed.

Turbos are also much more complicated to attach to an existing engine and require some pretty impressive engineering to ensure that the serious temperatures involved in the exhaust aren’t transferred to the air inlet. There is also an extensive modification needed to any existing exhaust system, with the amount of expansion in the manifold meaning the use of expensive, heat resistant materials.

In comparison, a supercharger can be bolted on relatively simply and at far less cost, without the need to deal with such high temperatures, or interfering with existing mechanisms unduly. Accordingly, this also makes them easier to maintain.

Superchargers do need a little warming up initially, however turbochargers need a quite comprehensive shutdown procedure. This is because, unlike superchargers, turbos are oil cooled and will overheat of they are simply shut down with the engine.

Blowers in the past tended to work very well at lower speeds, where turbos came into their own at higher rpm. There have been occasions where designers have actually employed both on an engine to take advantage of this disparity, however the cost and indeed weight disadvantage to doing so has prevented a bigger uptake of this idea.

Superchargers can rob an engine of as much as 20% of their efficiency, however, they can supply an additional 46% horsepower, so the trade-off is usually considered worthwhile. However, as they operate directly off the engine, they also require a robust driving mechanism to cope with the additional strain, whereas the turbo avoids this engine strain entirely. Superchargers also work best with higher octane fuel, again adding to costs.

When all is said and done, the complexity and overall cost of a turbo combined with the lag tends to give the win to superchargers, which can after all, still increase the power by between 50-100%.

For those of you unafraid of the extra complication, the ultimate solution is Twincharging. This is where both a turbo and a supercharger are used on the same engine, no decision needed! While it sounds like something reserved for race cars it's actually ridiculously practical, helping everyday cars meet new EU emissions tests whilst matching the power of previous engines. 

In the battle of Supercharger versus Turbo its Twincharging that wins.

 

 

 

Loading…
Your Vehicle

Set your vehicle so that we can automatically filter wheels
that will fit your vehicle as you browse our website.

1
2
3

Finance Calculator


A full range of finance options are available at checkout. Use our handy calculator to work out which option suits you. We also accept payment via Sagepay, Paypal, Visa, Maestro and Mastercard.


12 MonthsOption 1
Payable Today
Cost per Month
Total Payable
Cost of Credit
24 MonthsOption 2
Payable Today
Cost per Month
Total Payable
Cost of Credit
36 MonthsOption 3
Payable Today
Cost per Month
Total Payable
Cost of Credit
48 MonthsOption 4
Payable Today
Cost per Month
Total Payable
Cost of Credit

Typical Interest Rate: .
Only available to UK residents over 18, subject to terms and conditions. Rates of finance offered in this calculator are based on this specific product and can be applied for once this item has been added to basket and you have completed your order. Please remember to complete your finance application at the end of the checkout process.

Total loan amount must exceed £250 so deposit percentages may vary depending on the total basket amount.

All figures quoted are accurate to the best of our ability. However, some small differences may occur in calculations between our website and Pay4Later.

Pay4Later is Licensed by The Office of Fair Trading.